How Haiti and Panama abolished
their military
by Johan
Galtung and Dietrich Fischer
Most Haitians do not see their army
as a force that protects
them from aggression. They rather see it as a threat to
their personal security. It has violently overthrown democratically
elected governments and carried out arbitrary arrests,
torture and murders.
Oscar Arias Sanchez,
former President of Costa Rica, who won
the 1987 Nobel Peace Prize for his role in ending the war
in Nicaragua, estimated
from informal conversations with many ordinary
Haitians after the restoration of democracy in October
1994 that about 80 percent of them wished the military
were abolished. He
suggested to Haiti's President Jean- Bertrand
Aristide to take a bold step before leaving office and
to make Haiti join the growing list of countries without
a military. There are
about 30 such countries today, most of them
small islands or land-locked countries.
The agreement brokered in October
1994 by President Jimmy Carter
between Aristide and army chief General Raoul Cedras, which
led to the restoration of democracy without major bloodshed,
had already included a provision to reduce the Haitian
army from about 7,500 to 1,500 troops. But while this was
hardly enough to defend the country against an invasion,
it was still plenty to
overthrow an elected government. Haiti is
better off without army.
At a meeting in February 1995 with
Global Demilitarization,
a citizens group founded by Sue and Marvin Clark
from Troy, New York, Arias explained his informal findings
about the Haitian public's desire to abolish the military,
but remarked sadly that if he said so, the world press
paid no attention. However, if an internationally recognized
polling firm conducted a professional opinion poll in
Haiti and could confirm his impressions, he hoped the world
would pay more
attention. He said that his Foundation for Peace
and Reconciliation in San Jose, Costa Rica, sought the
relatively modest sum
of $20,000 to conduct an opinion poll in Haiti
on the question of abolishing the military.
That was before the parliamentary
elections of June 1995 in
Haiti. If such a poll was conducted, he expected reporters
to ask candidates about
their view on this issue, and those who
wanted to keep the military would be unlikely to win. Those
politicians who promised to favor abolition of themilitary to get
elected could then be held accountable by grassroots
organizations to keep their promise after the elections.
Global Demilitarization was able to
raise the necessary funds,
and the poll was conducted in Haiti in March and early
April 1995. Events
moved even more rapidly than Arias had expected,
and his strategy proved to be a great success. At a
news conference in Port-au-Prince on April 28, 1995, Arias
could announce that 62
percent of the Haitian people wished to abolish
the army, and only 12 percent wished to keep it, with the
rest undecided. When President Aristide heard these results,
he stepped to the microphone and spontaneously announced,
in front of the assembled military leadership, that given
the clear wish of the majority of his people, he herewith
declared the army abolished!
The American media almost totally
ignored this important event.
But President Aristide, when asked in an interview after
the election of his successor what he considered his greatest
achievement during his term in office, he said abolishing
the Haitian military.
Oscar Arias has had previous
successes. After President Guillermo
Endara was installed to office in Panama in December 1989
by U.S. troops who ousted strongman Manuel Noriega, no
Latin American country
was willing to recognize him, even though
he had won a democratic election. Latin Americans, for
good historical
reasons, have a strong aversion against U.S. intervention
in their internal affairs. Endara desperately sought
recognition from some Latin American governments. Arias,
then President of Costa Rica, saw an opportunity and promised
that his country would become the first in Latin America
to recognize Endara's government if he promised in return
to work for the abolition of Panama's military. Since the
military had just been defeated and disbanded, this required
no special effort. Endara gladly agreed. The Arias Foundation
then invited some Panamanian legislators to Costa Rica
to show them that a country without military is possible
and functions normally.
Some initial contacts with Panamanian voluntary
organizations helped them launch a campaign to abolish
the military. In October 1994, a provision was enshrined
in the Panamanian constitution that the country will have
no military. Costa Rica had taken the same step in 1949
under the leadership of
President Jose ("Don Pepe") Figueres.
Arias understood the
sensitivity of such an issue: pressure
had to come from inside the country, not from abroad, otherwise
it could backfire. That is why he also recognized the
importance of an opinion poll in Haiti to make the public
sentiment--so well
hidden under the past repressive conditions--visible.
When Costa Rica abolished its
military, it took precautions
to guard against any future coups. The police is not
under a single command, but divided between the ministries
for rural and urban
security. In this way, no police chief can
exert monopoly control and seize state power by force.
A Central Comptroller's Office
oversees all public expenditures
to prevent corruption. An election tribunal has the
task of preventing electoral fraud. Autonomous institutions,
in which opposition parties are represented, are responsible
for electricity, water, telecommunication and banking.
Political power is widely dispersed, to make it difficult
for any small group to seize illegitimate power.
Finally, Costa Rica relies on the
collective security mechanisms
of the United Nations and the Organization of American States. Other
countries can benefit from its experience. While other Central
American countries have long suffered
from war and military coups and squandered much of their
resources on the military, Costa Rica has enjoyed peace,
stable democracy, and
its per capita income is double that of its
neighbors.
Arias has also suffered some
setbacks. He tried hard to persuade
President Violetta Chamorro to abolish the Nicaraguan army
after her election victory in 1990, but she did not quite
have the courage to do
so. The Sandinistas had just lost an election
and would not have dared to overthrow her government. At
least, the army was reduced from 80,000 to 20,000 troops.
Overall, Oscar Arias' contribution
to peace and demilitarization
is impressive. One individual, with dedication,
persistence and clear thinking, can make an amazing
difference. In El Salvador, a reduction in the size of
the army is part of the recent peace accord. In Guatemala,
this question is under
negotiation. Arias dreams of a totally demilitarized
Central America, and ultimately a demilitarizedworld.
_________________________________________________________
Johan Galtung, a Professor of Peace
Studies at the University of
Hawaii and the European Peace University, Austria, is a
former teacher of Oscar
Arias at the University of Essex, England.
Dietrich Fischer, a
Professor at Pace University, is a
board member of Global Demilitarization. His latest book is
"Nonmilitary
Aspects of Security: A Systems Approach".
|